Feed Articles Screener

High oil prices were supposed to sink them, but these 3 cruise lines are reporting records and expect further growth

Oil surged to $138 a barrel this year, and cruise lines, which burn hundreds of thousands of tons of it annually, were supposed to take the hardest hit. Instead, all three largest cruise operators raised their earnings outlooks, yet the market pays almost twice as much for a dollar of earnings at one as at another.

Key points

  • Oil surged to $138 a barrel in April, yet all three largest cruise operators raised their earnings outlooks.

  • The market pays $18.8 for a dollar of earnings at one of these companies, and just under ten at another.

  • Two bond issues this fall, one at 5.55% and the other at 8.75%, explain the difference better than earnings do.

  • The sector's cheapest stock carries $14.8 billion in net debt and negative free cash flow over the past 12 months.

  • Three specific dates between December and early March will determine which discount is real.

Same ocean, three very different price tags

This year was supposed to sink cruise lines. The closed Strait of Hormuz sent Brent crude as high as $138 a barrel in April, and ships that burn hundreds of thousands of tons of fuel a year were among the first casualties on the stock market. But then something few expected happened this fall: all three largest companies in the industry raised their full-year earnings outlooks, and as Brent fell back to around $92, their shares rose 9.5 to 18% over the past month.

At first glance, then, it's one sector and one piece of good news. But look at the price tags and the picture falls apart. For every dollar of earnings, you pay $18.8 for Royal Caribbean $RCL, 12.4 for Carnival $CCL and just under ten for Norwegian Cruise Line $NCLH.

Company

Price

52-week high

Below high

P/E

One-year return

Royal Caribbean

320.65 USD

356.39 USD

-10.0 %

18.8

+25.3 %

Carnival

28.97 USD

34.03 USD

-14.9 %

12.4

+11.1 %

Norwegian

17.99 USD

25.13 USD

-28.4 %

9.9

+1.2 %

Same ocean, same customers, same oil. So why does the market value one company as a growth story and another as a bargain-bin stock? Two bond issues this fall explain it best: one at 5.55% and the other at 8.75%.

Royal Caribbean: what you're paying the sector's highest price for

Royal Caribbean earned $6.57 per share in the third quarter on revenue of $5.6 billion, up 9% from last year and above its own outlook. It raised its full-year outlook to $17.85-$17.95 per share, which matters more than it may seem: the midpoint of $17.90 is exactly what the company forecast in January, before the oil shock. Higher fuel costs were therefore fully offset by stronger demand.

Bookings for 2027 are up just under 20% at higher prices since the last analyst call, and management is sticking to its target of earning more than $20 per share next year. It is also buying the other half of the Sandals Caribbean resort network and borrowed $1.25 billion through bonds in the third quarter at 5.55%, the lowest rate in the industry.

"I understand that there has been a lot of noise in the market this year. There's a lot of geopolitics, but when I look at our business: our original outlook for this year had a midpoint of $17.90. The midpoint of our outlook today is $17.90."

Jason Liberty, Chairman and CEO of Royal Caribbean Group

But that reliability comes at a price. A P/E of 18.8 is above the industry average (16.8), and Bulios' fair value of $260 is 19% below the market price. The stock is priced for cruise fares to stay higher in 2027, so even the slightest faltering in prices matters most here.

Carnival: half the price and half of 2027 already booked

Carnival reported record net income of $1.9 billion for its fiscal third quarter and raised its full-year outlook to $2.24 per share. Customers have a record $7.6 billion in deposits for future cruises, and CEO Josh Weinstein said on the analyst call that half of 2027 is already booked at record occupancy and prices.

"For the full year 2027, booked occupancy and pricing are at record levels, providing a strong foundation for another year of solid revenue growth. And looking further ahead, 2028 is off to an excellent start too, with occupancy and pricing higher than this time last year."

Josh Weinstein, CEO of Carnival Corporation

The biggest improvement, though, is on the balance sheet. Debt, which peaked at $36 billion in 2023, has fallen below $24 billion; the company repaid $500 million of 7% bonds early this summer and earned a second investment-grade rating. It also repurchased $1.2 billion worth of shares this year. All this comes at a P/E of 12.4 and a free cash flow yield of 8.2%; Bulios' fair value is $38.97, a third above the current share price.

The catch: according to Weinstein, the spring booking slowdown also carried into the first quarter of 2027, the new loyalty program is weighing on reported revenue in accounting terms, and the new ships on order, the first of which will arrive in 2029, will push investment back up. The first test comes with full-year fiscal results around December 18.

Norwegian: the cheapest stock has the most expensive debt

A P/E just under ten looks like a bargain, but at $17.99 you're buying earnings that are expected to fall next year. Norwegian did raise its outlook to $1.70 per share, but revenue per available passenger berth is down 4.4% this year, it expects an adjusted loss of $0.12 per share in the fourth quarter, and analyst consensus for 2027 is $1.40, below this year's level. The company itself says its bookings remain "below the optimal range" and that the first half of 2027 is less well booked than it was at this time last year.

"While we are behind the booking curve in the first half of the year, as we've made very clear, when you look at the second half and where we are on the curve, along with our new presale strategy, we can probably improve from here. I'm certainly not saying we're at the optimal point."

John Chidsey, Chairman and CEO of Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings

Then there's the debt. Net debt of $14.8 billion is 5.5 times EBITDA, almost twice Royal Caribbean's, and free cash flow is negative over the past 12 months (-$531 million). When Norwegian borrowed $950 million in October, it paid 8.75% annually, more than three percentage points above its rival. CFO Mark Kempa is also leaving at year-end after more than 25 years with the company.

The company has more than $600 million in savings, a new water park on its private island, Great Stirrup Cay, and a promise that prices will rise 1 to 2% in 2027. Bulios' fair value of $24.35 is 35% above the market price, but the discount is real only if the turnaround actually arrives.

What will matter: three dates and one price per barrel

  • December 18, Carnival: full-year fiscal results. Watch whether 2027 bookings continue to grow and debt keeps falling even after billions in share buybacks. If so, a P/E of twelve is the clearest bargain in the sector.

  • February 4, 2027, Royal Caribbean: its first full-year outlook for 2027. Will it confirm $20 per share or not? Anything below that means the 18.8 P/E premium is on shaky ground.

  • March 1, 2027, Norwegian: how did the so-called wave season go, the January-to-March period when most cruises are sold? If first-half 2027 doesn't fill up, the "ten times earnings" valuation will turn into a higher multiple on lower earnings, even if the stock doesn't rise.

  • Oil: Brent below $90 helps everyone; above $100 hurts Norwegian most. Royal Caribbean has hedged 53% of its 2027 fuel needs at $405 per ton, while Norwegian has hedged 42% at $559 per ton.

There are three possible scenarios. If cruise prices hold up, Royal Caribbean will justify its premium and Carnival will catch up with the least risk. If Norwegian manages a turnaround, it offers the biggest percentage move in the sector. And if bookings don't accelerate in January, the cheapest stock will stay cheap for a good reason.

Before your next step

No single piece of content is a reason to buy or sell. Investors on Bulios decide based on their own analysis. Our academy teaches you how, step by step.

Open the academy How Bulios content is made is described by our editorial standards.

Follow Bulios on Google News

Be among the first to discover new analyses, news and market moves.

Follow

Recommended articles

Read more

AI power stocks fell by a third. Constellation and Vistra are raising their earnings outlooks

Two major US electricity producers serving data centers have lost more than 35% of their value from their yearly highs. Investors were spooked by Texas, where the new governor wants to halt data center construction. But the companies still have contracts lasting twenty years.

MC
Milan Charvat
· 3h
Read more
BLACK

Money Is Flowing Into These ETFs

While technology stocks experienced their worst month since spring 2025, capital is not fleeing the market. It is moving. One of the biggest beneficiaries of this year's rotation is U.S. industry and infrastructure. Three funds in this segment have attracted a net $6.3 billion since the start of…

KJ
Kryštof Jáně
· 1d
Read more
BLACK

Dividends Above 10%? No Problem for These Stocks

A yield of over 15% a year sounds almost unbelievable in the stock market, yet several established US-listed securities are offering just that today. Mortgage REITs and leveraged bond funds earn money from the difference between the yield on mortgages or bonds and the cost of short-term financing,…

KJ
Kryštof Jáně
· 2d

We use essential cookies to run the website and optional analytics cookies to measure usage.

Privacy policy